
For frail older adults with failing kidneys, dialysis didn't beat a no-dialysis plan
- Randomized trial
- 445 frail or multimorbid older adults
- average 4.5 years
When an older person's kidneys fail, many families assume dialysis comes next. Dialysis does the kidneys' job of filtering the blood and usually means several hospital sessions a week. A UK trial asked whether, for the frailest patients, planning for it leads to better lives.
The Prepare for Kidney Care trial, published in The Lancet, enrolled 445 people from 31 UK kidney centres, about half of the country's kidney services. About three in four were 80 or older. The rest were 65 to 79 with other health problems. Each person was randomly assigned to prepare either for dialysis or for 'responsive management', a structured form of kidney care without dialysis. They were followed for an average of 4.5 years.
Neither plan came out ahead when length and quality of life were weighed together. Only 28% of those preparing for dialysis ever started it. In both groups, people were more likely to die from other causes than to reach the point of needing dialysis.
It is the first randomized trial of its kind, and it covers a narrow group: older people with kidney failure plus frailty or several conditions. It says nothing about people already on dialysis or younger, fitter patients. Everyone knew which plan they were on. The public summaries also leave out the detailed survival and quality-of-life figures, so how the two paths differed day to day is not yet clear.
Get the next issue by email
Our weekly newsletter on what is new in health research, explained for curious readers and linked to the original studies. One email a week.
Sources
Source titles are preserved as published.
- Prepare for responsive management or renal dialysis in older people living with kidney failure and frailty or multimorbidity (Prepare for Kidney Care): a multi-centre, randomised, unblinded, phase 3, superiority trial · The Lancet
- Dialysis may not be the default treatment for older kidney patients · News-Medical
- Kidney care trial challenges default dialysis planning for older adults with frailty · Medical Xpress
Reference Range Weekly is for general information. It does not provide medical advice, diagnosis, or treatment.